Spine discectomy and fusion is a widely used surgical procedure to correct irreversible degenerative diseases and injuries to the intervertebral disk. The surgical procedure involves the removal of the damage disk material, the decortication of the fusion site, and the placement of the bone graft. Fusion is believed to generate additional stresses in the neighboring disks, which can subsequently lead to new disk degeneration and re-operation. The autologous bone has proven to be the best material for the fusion. However, the autologous bone has three major disadvantages: the high rate of donor site morbidity, the limited and sometimes poor quality of the amounts of bone available, and the extra operative time needed for harvest. For these reasons this study is undertaken to estimate the optimum amount of bone graft needed for a discectomy and correlate it to the change in stress in adjacent levels. A detailed and validated 3D finite element model of the complete human cervical spine (C1-T1) was altered to simulate segmental full and partial discectomies. One full fusion (bone graft occupies about 90% of the vertebral body) and seven partial fusions (bone graft occupies about 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 65%, and 75% of the vertebral body) were simulated at each of the four mid- and lower single levels of the cervical spine and the relationship between the change in stresses in the adjacent levels and the bone graft size (area) was studied. The changes in stress were compared with the previously obtained results of the unfused models. The fused and unfused models were preloaded with a 73.6 N compressive force representing the weight of the head and with a 1.5 Nm physiological moment in flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation. More than 132 cases were analyzed. The results showed that the necessary amount of bone graft needed for discectomy depends on the cervical disk level to be fused and varies between 30% and 75% of the disk area. The results also suggested that there is a threshold size of the bone graft area, before and/or after which, the long-term effects of the change in stresses in adjacent disks are biomechanically consequential.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
1.
Shao
, Z.
, Rompe
, G.
, and Schiltenwolf
, M.
, 2002, “Radiographic Changes in the Lumbar Intervertebral Discs and Lumbar Vertebrae With Age
,” Spine
0362-2436, 27
, pp. 263
–268
.2.
Panjabi
, M. M.
, Dvorak
, J.
, Sandler
, A.
, Goel
, V.
, and White
, A. A.
, III, 1998, “Cervical Spine Kinematics and Clinical Instability
,” The Cervical Spine
, 3rd ed., pp. 53
–77
.3.
The Cervical Research Society Editorial Committee
, 1998, The Cervical Spine
, 3rd ed., Lippincott-Raven
, Philadelphia, PA
.4.
Humzad
, M. D.
, and Soames
, R. W.
, 1988, “Human Intervertebral Disc: Structure and Function, Review
,” Anat. Rec.
0003-276X, 220
, pp. 337
–356
.5.
Oda
, J.
, Tanaka
, H.
, and Tsuzuki
, N.
, 1988, “Intervertebral Disc Changes With Aging of Human Cervical Vertebra. From the Neonate to the Eighties
,” Spine
0362-2436, 13
, pp. 1205
–1341
.6.
Torrens
, M. J.
, and Miliaras
, G.
, 2002, “Cervical Spondylosis. Part II: Surgical Management
,” Curr. Orthop.
, 16
, pp. 300
–310
. 0268-08907.
Iseda
, T.
, Goya
, T.
, Nakano
, S.
, Kodama
, T.
, Moriyama
, T.
, and Wakisaka
, S.
, 2001, “Serial Changes in Signal Intensities of the Adjacent Discs on T2-Weigthed Sagittal Images After Surgical Treatment of Cervical Spondylosis: Anterior Interbody Fusion Versus Expansive Laminoplasty
,” Acta Neurochir. (Wien)
, 143
, pp. 707
–710
. 0001-62688.
Teramoto
, T.
, Ohmari
, K.
, Takatsu
, T.
, Inove
, H.
, Ishida
, Y.
, and Suzuki
, K.
, 1994, “Long term Results of Anterior Cervical Spondylosis
,” Neurosurgery
0148-396X, 35
, pp. 64
–68
.9.
Bernard
, T. N. J.
, Whitecloud
, T. S.
III, 1987, “Cervical Spondylotic Myelopathy and Myeloradiculopathy. Anterior Decompression and Stabilization With Autogenous Fibula Strut Graft
,” Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.
0009-921X, 221
, pp. 149
–160
.10.
Hilibrand
, A. S.
, Yoo
, J. U.
, Carlson
, G. D.
, and Bohlman
, H. H.
, 1997, “The Success of Anterior Cervical Arthrodesis Adjacent to Previous Fusion
,” Spine
0362-2436, 22
, pp. 1574
–1579
.11.
Ebersold
, M. J.
, Pare
, M. C.
, and Quast
, L. M.
, 1995, “Surgical Treatment for Cervical Spondylotic Myelopathy
,” J. Neurosurg.
0022-3085, 82
, pp. 745
–751
.12.
Okada
, K.
, Shirasaki
, N.
, Hayashi
, H.
, Oka
, S.
, and Hosoya
, T.
, 1991, “Treatment of Cervical Spondylotic Myelopathy by Enlargement of the Spinal Canal Anteriorly, Followed by Arthrodesis
,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Am. Vol.
0021-9355, 73
, pp. 352
–364
.13.
Saunders
, R. L.
, Bernini
, P. M.
, Shirreffs
, T. G. J.
, and Reeves
, A. G.
, 1991, “Central Corpectomy for Cervical Spondylotic Myelopathy: A Consecutive Series With Long Term Follow-Up Evaluation
,” J. Neurosurg.
0022-3085, 74
, pp. 163
–170
.14.
Shinomiya
, K.
, Okamoto
, A.
, Kamikozuru
, N.
, Furuya
, K.
, and Yamaura
, I.
, 1993, “An Analysis of Failures in Primary Cervical Anterior Spinal Cord Decompression And Fusion
,” J. Spinal Disord.
0895-0385, 6
, pp. 277
–288
.15.
Clements
, D. H.
, and O’Leary
, P. F.
, 1990, “Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion
,” Spine
0362-2436, 15
, pp. 1023
–1025
.16.
Gore
, D. R.
, and Sepic
, S. B.
, 1998, “Anterior Discectomy and Fusion for Painful Cervical Disc Disease: A Report of 50 Patients With an Average Follow Up of 21 Years
,” Spine
0362-2436, 23
, pp. 2047
–2051
.17.
Gore
, D. R.
, and Sepic
, S. B.
, 1984, “Anterior Cervical Fusion for Degenerated or Protruded Discs: A Review of One Hundred Forty Six Patients
,” Spine
0362-2436, 9
, pp. 667
–671
.18.
Profeta
, G.
, de Falco
, R.
, Ianniciello
, G.
, Profeta
, L.
, Cigliano
, A.
, and Raja
, I. A.
, 2000, “Preliminary Experience With Anterior Cervical Microdisectomy and Interbody Titanium Cage Fusion (Novus CT-Ti) in Patients With Cervical Disc Disease
,” Surg. Neurol.
0090-3019, 53
, pp. 417
–26
.19.
Portnoy
, H. D.
, 2001, “Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion
,” Surg. Neurol.
0090-3019, 56
, pp. 178
–180
.20.
Cloward
, R. B.
, 1958, “The Anterior Approach for Removal of Rupture Cervical Discs
,” J. Neurosurg.
0022-3085, 15
, pp. 602
–17
.21.
Gill
, K.
, and Lin
, P. M.
, 1989, Lumbar Interbody Fusion
, Maryland Aspen Pub
, Rockville
, pp. 3
–7
.22.
Kowalski
, R. J.
, Ferrara
, L. A.
, and Benzel
, E. C.
, 2001, “Biomechanics of Bone Fusion
,” Neurosurg. Focus
, 10
(4
), pp. 1
–7
. 1092-068423.
Closkey
, R. F.
, Russell Parsons
, J.
, Lee
, C. K.
, Blacksin
, M. F.
, and Zimmerman
, M. C.
, 1993, “Mechanics of Interbody Spinal Fusion: Analysis of Critical Bone Graft Area
,” Spine
0362-2436, 18
, pp. 1011
–1015
.24.
Yoganandan
, N.
, Kumaresan
, S. C.
, Voo
, L.
, Pintar
, F. A.
, and Larson
, S. J.
, 1996, “Finite Element Modeling of C4-C6 Cervical Spine Unit
,” Med. Eng. Phys.
1350-4533, 18
(7
), pp. 569
–574
.25.
Teo
, E. C.
, Paul
, J. P.
, and Evans
, J. H.
, 1994, “Finite Element Stress Analysis of a Cadaver Second Cervical Vertebra
,” Med. Biol. Eng. Comput.
0140-0118, 32
, pp. 236
–238
.26.
Maurel
, N.
, Lavaste
, F.
, and Skalli
, W.
, 1997, “A Three-Dimensional Parameterized Finite Element Model of the Lower Cervical Spine, Study of the Influence of the Posterior Articular Facets
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 30
, pp. 921
–931
.27.
Goel
, V. K.
and Clausen
, J. D.
, 1998, “Prediction of Load Sharing Among Spinal Components of a C5-C6 Motion Segment Using the Finite Element Approach
,” Spine
0362-2436, 23
(6
), pp. 684
–691
.28.
Brolin
, K.
, and Halldin
, P.
, 2004, “Development of a Finite Element Model of the Upper Cervical Spine and a Parameter Study of Ligament Characteristics
,” Spine
0362-2436, 29
(4
), pp. 376
–385
.29.
Clausen
, J.
, Goel
, V. K.
, Traynelis
, V. C.
, and Wilder
, D. G.
, 1996, “Cervical Spine Biomechanical Investigation Using an Experimentally Validated FE Model of C5-C6 Motion Segment
,” Transaction of 42nd Annual Meeting, Orthopaedic Research Society
, Atlanta, GA, Feb. 18–22, p. 657
.30.
Bozic
, K. J.
, Keyak
, J. H.
, Skinner
, H. B.
, Bueff
, H. U.
, and Bradford
, D. S.
, 1994, “Three-Dimensional Finite Element Modeling of a Cervical Vertebra: An Investigation of Burst Fracture Mechanism
,” J. Spinal Disord.
0895-0385, 7
, pp. 102
–110
.31.
Bono
, C. M.
, Faizan
, A.
, Goel
, V. K.
, and Garfin
, S. R.
, 2006, “Finite Element Analysis of Motion With Solid Cervical Fusion: Implications on Interpreting Flexion-Extension Radiographs
,” 52nd Annual Meeting, Orthopedic Research Society
, Chicago, IL, Mar. 19–22.32.
Bono
, C. M.
, Khandha
, A.
, Vadapalli
, S.
, Holekamp
, S.
, Goel
, V. K.
, and Garfin
, S. R.
, 2007, “Residual Sagittal Motion After Lumbar Fusion—A Finite Element Analysis With Implications on Radiographic Flexion-Extension Criteria
,” Spine
0362-2436, 32
(4
), pp. 417
–422
.33.
Goel
, V. K.
, Panjabi
, M. M.
, Patwardhan
, A. G.
, Dooris
, A. P.
, and Serhan
, H.
, 2006, “Test Protocols for Spinal Implants
,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Am. Vol.
0021-9355, 88
, pp. 103
–109
.34.
Kumaresan
, S. C.
, 1997, “Clinical Studies of the Human Cervical Spine Using Finite Element Modeling
,” Ph.D. thesis, Marquette University, Milwaukee, WI.35.
Kumaresan
, S.
, Yoganandan
, N.
, and Pintar
, F. A.
, 1997, “Finite Element Analysis of Anterior Cervical Spine Interbody Fusion
,” Biomed. Mater. Eng.
0959-2989, 7
(4
), pp. 221
–230
.36.
Nataragan
, R. N.
, Chen
, B. H.
, An
, H. S.
, and Anderson
, G. B. J.
, 1999, “Biomechanical Analysis of Cervical Discectomy and Fusion Using a Three Segment Model
,” 23rd Annual Meeting of the American Society of Biomechanics
, Pittsburgh, PA.37.
Chen
, C. S.
, Cheng
, C. K.
, Liu
, C. L.
, and Lo
, W. H.
, 2001a, “Stress Analysis of the Disc Adjacent to Interbody Fusion in Lumbar Spine
,” Med. Eng. Phys.
1350-4533, 23
, pp. 485
–493
.38.
Natarajan
, R. N.
, Chen
, B. H.
, An
, H. S.
, and Andersson
, G. B.
, 2000, “Anterior Cervical Fusion: A Finite Element Model Study on Motion Segment Stability Including the Effect of Osteoporosis
,” Spine
0362-2436, 25
(8
), pp. 955
–961
.39.
Chen
, B. H.
, Natarajan
, R. N.
, An
, H. S.
, and Anderson
, G. B.
, 2001, “Investigated the Anterior and Comparison of Biomechanical Response to Surgical Procedures Used for Cervical Radiculopathy: Posterior Keyhole Foraminotomy Versus Anterior Foraminotomy and Discectomy Versus Anterior Discectomy With Fusion
,” J. Spinal Disord.
0895-0385, 14
(1
), pp. 17
–20
.40.
Ha
, S. K.
, 2006, “Finite Element Modeling of Multi-Level Cervical Spinal Segments (C3-C6) and Biomechanical Analysis of an Elastomer-Type Prosthetic Disc
,” Med. Eng. Phys.
1350-4533, 28
(6
), pp. 534
–541
.41.
Yoganandan
, N.
, Kumaresan
, S.
, and Pintar
, F. A.
, 2001, “Biomechanics of the Cervical Spine Part 2. Cervical Spine Soft Tissue Responses and Biomechanical Modeling
,” Clin. Biomech. (Bristol, Avon)
0268-0033, 16
(1
), pp. 1
–27
.42.
Liu
, Y. K.
, Krieger
, K. W.
, Njus
, G.
, Ueno
, K.
, Connors
, M. P.
, Wakano
, K.
, and Thies
, D.
, 1982, “Cervical Spine Stiffness and Geometry of the Young Human Male
,” Air Force Medical Research Laboratory, Ohio, Report No. AFAMRL-TR-80-138.43.
Sadegh
, A.
and Tchako
, A.
, 2000, “Vertebral Stress of a Cervical Spine Model Under Dynamic Load
,” Technol. Health Care
0928-7329, 8
(2
), pp 163
–154
.44.
Yoganandan
, N.
, Myklebust
, J. B.
, Ray
, G.
, and Sances
, A.
, Jr., 1987, “Mathematical and Finite Element Analysis of Spine Injuries
,” Crit. Rev. Biomed. Eng.
0278-940X, 15
(1
), pp. 29
–93
.45.
Shirazi-Adl
, A.
, Ahmed
, A. M.
, and Shrivasta
, S. C.
, 1986, “A Finite Element Study of a Lumber Motion Segment Subjected to Pure Sagittal Plane Moments
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 19
(4
), pp. 331
–350
.46.
de Jager
, M.
, Sauren
, A.
, Thunnissen
, J.
, and Wismans
, J.
, 1994, “A Three-Dimensional Head-Neck Model: Validation for Frontal and Lateral Impacts
,” Society of Automotive Engineers, SAE Paper No. 942211.47.
Grossheim
, L.
, 1989, “Morphology of the Human Cervical Spine
,” MS thesis, Marquette University, Milwaukee, WI.48.
Pintar
, F. A.
, 1986, “Biomechanics of Spine Elements
,” Ph.D. thesis, Marquette University, Milwauke, WI.49.
1999,
ANSYS User Manual, Version 5.6
, Swanson Analysis Systems, Inc
, Houston, PA
.50.
Tchako
, A.
, 2005, “Sport Injury Biomechanics and Stress Changes in Adjacent Intervertebral Discs After Partial Discectomies and Fusion of the Cervical Spine
,” Ph.D. thesis, The City University of New York, New York.51.
Tchako
, A.
, and Sadegh
, A.
, 2009, “A Cervical Spine Model to Predict Injury Scenarios and Clinical Instability
,” Journal of Sport Biomechanics, 8(1), pp. 78–95.52.
Moroney
, S. P.
, Schultz
, A. B.
, Miller
, J. A.
, and Anderson
, G. B.
, 1988, “Load Displacement Properties of Lower Cervical Spine Motion Segments
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 21
, pp. 769
–779
.53.
Goel
, V. K.
, and Clausen
, J. D.
, 1998, “Prediction of Load Sharing Among Spinal Components of a C5-C6 Motion Segment Using the Finite Element Approach
,” Spine
0362-2436, 23
, pp. 684
–691
.54.
Shea
, M.
, Edwards
, W. T.
, White
, A. A.
, and Hayes
, W. C.
, 1991, “Variations of Stiffness and Strength Along the Human Cervical Spine
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 24
(2
) pp. 95
–107
.55.
Panjabi
, M. M.
, Summers
, D. J.
, Pelker
, R. R.
, Viedeman
, T.
, Friedlander
, G. E.
, and Southwick
, W. O.
, 1986, “Three Dimensional Load-Displacement Curves Due to Forces on the Cervical Spine
,” J. Orthop.
, 4
, pp. 152
–161
.56.
White
, A. A.
, and Panjabi
, M. M.
, 1990, Clinical Biomechanics of the Spine
,” 2nd ed., JB Lippincott
, Philadelphia, PA
, p. 321
.57.
Fuller
, D. A.
, Kirkpatrick
, J. S.
, Emery
, S. E.
, Wiber
, R. G.
, and Davy
, D. T.
, 1998, “A Kinematic Study of the Cervical Spine Before and After Segmental Arthrodesis
,” Spine
0362-2436, 23
, pp. 1649
–1656
.58.
Smith
, G. W.
, and Robinson
, R. A.
, 1958, “The Treatment of Certain Cervical Spine Disorders by Anterior Removal of the Intervertebral Disc and Interbody Fusion
,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Am. Vol.
0021-9355, 40
, pp. 607
–624
.59.
Adams
, M. A.
, and Huton
, W. C.
, 1988, “Mechanics of the Intervertebral Disc
,” The Biology of Intervertebral Disc
, P.
Ghosh
, ed., CRC Press Inc.
, Florida
, Vol. 2
.60.
Gercek
, E.
, Arlet
, V.
, Delisle
, J.
, and Marchesi
, D.
, 2003, “Subsidence of Stand-Alone Cervical Cages in Anterior Interbody Fusion: Warning
,” J. Neurosurg.
0022-3085, 12
(5
), pp. 513
–516
.61.
Cowin
, S. C.
, 1986, “Wolff’s Law of Trabecular Architecture at Remodeling Equilibrium
,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng.
0148-0731, 108
(1
), pp. 83
–88
.62.
Cowin
, S. C.
, Sadegh
, M. A.
, and Luo
, G. M.
, 1992 “An Evolutionary Wolff’s Law for Trabecular Architecture
,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng.
0148-0731, 114
(1
), pp. 129
–136
.63.
Kumar
, A.
, Kozak
, J. A.
, Doherty
, B. J.
, and Dickson
, J. H.
, 1993, “Interspace Distraction and Graft Subsidence After Anterior Lumbar Fusion With Femoral Strut Allograft
,” Spine
0362-2436, 18
, pp. 2393
–2400
.64.
Patel
, S. S.
, Timon
, S. J.
, Dawson
, E. G.
, Wang
, J. C.
, 2002, “Anterior Lumbar Discectomy and Fusion Using Femoral Ring Allografts
,” American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
, Dallas, TX, Feb. 13–17.65.
An
, H. S.
, Xu
, R.
, Lim
, T. H.
, McGrady
, L.
, and Wilson
, C.
, 1994, “Prediction of Bone Graft Strength Using Dual-Energy Radiographic Absorptiometry
,” Spine
0362-2436, 19
(20
), pp. 2358
–2363
.66.
Epstein
, N. E.
, 1998, “Evaluation and Treatment of Clinical Instability Associated With Pseudarthrosis After Anterior Cervical Surgery for Ossification of the Posterior Longitudinal Ligament
,” Surg. Neurol.
0090-3019, 49
, pp. 246
–252
.67.
Caspar
, W.
, and Pitzen
, T.
, 1999, “Anterior Cervical Fusion and Trapezoidal Plate Stabilization for Re-Do Surgery
,” Surg. Neurol.
0090-3019, 52
, pp. 345
–352
.68.
Wirth
, F. P.
, Dowd
, G. C.
, Sanders
, H. F.
, and Wirth
, C.
, 2000, “Cervical Discectomy: A Prospective Analysis of Three Operative Techniques
,” Surg. Neurol.
0090-3019, 53
, pp. 340
–348
.69.
Martins
, A.
, 1976, “Anterior Cervical Discectomy With and Without Interbody Bone Graft
,” J. Neurosurg.
0022-3085, 44
, pp. 290
–295
.70.
Dowd
, G. C.
, and Wirth
, F. P.
, 1999, “Anterior Cervical Discectomy: Is Fusion Necessary?
” J. Neurosurg.
0022-3085, 90
, pp. 8
–12
.71.
Flynn
, T. B.
, 1982, “Neurologic Complications of Anterior Cervical Interbody Fusion
,” Spine
0362-2436, 7
, pp. 536
–539
.72.
Pilitis
, J. G.
, Lucas
, D. R.
, and Rengachary
, S. R.
, 2002, “Bone Healing and Spinal Fusion
,” Neurosurg. Focus
, 13
(6
). 1092-068473.
Goel
, V. K.
, Park
, H.
, and Kong
, W.
, 1994, “Investigation of Vibration Characteristics of the Ligamentous Lumbar Spine Using the Finite Element Approach
,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng.
0148-0731, 116
(4
), pp. 377
–383
.74.
Van Mameran
, H.
, Sanches
, H.
, and Beursgens
, J.
, 1992, “Cervical Spine Motion in the Sagittal Plane. II. Position of Segmental Averaged Instantaneous Centers of Rotation—A Cineradiographic Study
,” Spine
0362-2436, 17
, pp. 467
–474
.75.
Lotz
, J. C.
, Hsieh
, A. H.
, Walsh
, A. L.
, Palmer
, E. I.
, and Chin
, J. R.
, 2002, “Mechanobiology of the Intervertebral Disc
,” Biochem. Soc. Trans.
0300-5127, 30
(6
), pp. 853
–858
.76.
Barley
, R. W.
, and Badgley
, C. E.
, 1960, “Stabilization of the Cervical Spine by Anterior Fusion
,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Am. Vol.
0021-9355, 42
, pp. 365
–394
.77.
Tchako
, A.
, and Sadegh
, A.
, 2002, “Stress Changes in Intervertebral Discs of the Cervical Spine After Arthrodesis
,” Bioengineering Division, Proceedings of the International Mech. Engr. Exposition
, BED/ASME, (IMECE), New Orleans, Nov.78.
Tchako
, A.
, and Sadegh
, A.
, 2001, “Instability Analysis of a Cervical Spine Model Under Flexion and Compression Loading
,” Bioengineering Division, Proceedings of the International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition
, BED/ASME, New York, Nov.Copyright © 2009
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
